Police in Himachal Pradesh have registered an FIR (first Information Report) against BJP MP Kangana Ranaut. It’s in relation to some of the posts she has made online about the Gandhi family. An FIR is simply the first report the police take down when they receive a complaint. It doesn’t in any way imply that anyone has been found guilty.

How Did It Start?

On Friday 13th November police in Shimla registered the case on a complaint by Atul Sharma (retired Captain, Shimla).

Sharma says Ranaut posted on her verified account on 10th November. “Verified” in this context means the platform has confirmed that it is indeed her account. The posts he points to refer to some rather unpleasant things about the deaths of the late PM Indira Gandhi and her sons Sanjay Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi.

What does the complaint say?

Sharma says the posts referred to Congress leader Sonia Gandhi as a “mysterious foreign national”. They also claimed she joined the family just prior to a number of family members dying one after the other and then ended up at the head of the government. The posts also included the phrase “How convenient”.

He also says the posts refer to Maneka Gandhi leaving the family home following Sanjay Gandhi’s death.

In Sharma’s view this was more than just political criticism. It could lead to people turning on each other, it could be a source of communal unrest and it could be the dissemination of misinformation which would frighten people.

What have the police done?

Sharma emailed his complaint to the Director General of Police on Thursday evening. He asked for an FIR and for a fast cyber-forensic investigation (which would involve the expert examination of the digital material, i.e. the online posts).

The case has been registered under Sections 196(1)(b), 353(2) and 356(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Superintendent of Police in Shimla, Gaurav Singh, has confirmed the FIR and stated that an investigation will ensue. The police are now going through the claims in the complaint.

Why were the posts shared now?

The timing of that was interesting. An old home video from circa 1981 was circulating online at the time and it’s of a family dinner with Indira, Sonia, Maneka and the young Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi.

The posts also came out on the same day that Sonia Gandhi’s memoir Belonging: A Journey of Love was released.

Earlier this week Ranaut was also asking on Instagram about the timing of Sonia Gandhi getting Indian citizenship in 1983. She was also criticising her ascent into politics.

What Happens Next?

For the moment all the complaint contains are allegations. The police haven’t said whether Ranaut breached any law. The reports I’ve been given don’t contain any response from her so we don’t yet know what her version of the story is.

Why Does It Matter?

In India people can express their views on leaders. There are also laws against the promotion of hatred and false information. This case is one of those where the line has to be drawn between the two. Only the investigation and then presumably the courts can determine where this case lies.